Morgan Carbon is a Division of Morgan Crucible


Commutator condition chart


Satisfactory Conditions

Light Film - over the entire commutator surface is one of the many normal conditions often seen on a well functioning machine. Film tone is dependent on the brush grade and current density.


Dark Film - if uniform over the entire commutator surface is acceptable. This condition can be the result of a high filming brush grade, higher current densities or the presence of chemical vapour contamination. 


Blotchy Film - this non uniform filming condition is the most common appearance. The accumulated tolerances in the machine such as commutator roundness brush contact pressure, unequal magnetic fields and chemical vapours all contribute to this type of film development. 


Slot bar Filming - repeating light end dark filming patterns related to the number of armature coils per slot. This pattern is dependent on the machine design and usually not a function of the brush grade.  

Conditions of Concern

Streaking - of only the film is not detrimental to the commutator. Brush and commutator life are not at risk in this condition. If metal transfer develops, this condition will progress into threading. This type of filming can be dependent on current density or brush grade.


Bright Spots - a freckled appearance of the film usually caused by machines that are subjected to frequent overload cycles. If the bright spots disturb only the film, a machine can operate for long periods of time with this condition. If severe metal transfer begins, the bright spots could progress to dangerous bar burning or film stripping. 

Unsatisfactory Conditions

Bar Burning - is the erosion of the trailing edge of the commutator bar. Failed machine components, misadjusted electrical symmetry of the machine or a poor commutating brush can result in bar burning. If not corrected, this condition can cause severe commutator damage or a flashover.


Slot Bar Burning - results in commutator erosion of every second, third, or fourth bar depending on the winding design of the armature. Improper brush material, brush design or electrical adjustment of the machine can cause this condition. This condition severely damages the commutator and reduces brush life.


Threading - is machining of the commutator by copper particles in the brush face. The excessive copper transfer occurs due to low spring pressure, light loading or contamination. These particles are trapped in the porous carbon brush and work harden, creating a tool that machines or Gaul's the commutator surface. The machine can operate for long periods of time with this condition, but reduced commutator and brush life will be experienced.


Pitch bar Burning - results in commutator bars being eroded in a pattern related to 1 /2 the number of brush arms, progressing into a pattern equal to the number of brush arms. This condition is caused by a cyclic mechanical or electrical disturbance such as, on unbalanced armature, misaligned shafts, bent shaft, bad bearings, weak foundation, foiled equalizers or a poor riser connection. If not corrected this condition will result in a flashover.


Grooving - is the uniform circumferential wear, the width of the brush that is exhibited on the commutator. Excessive abrasive dusts in the atmosphere or on abrasive brush can cause this condition. Extreme light spring pressure (below 1 .5 psi) can also cause this condition. Proper brush applications and filtering the air on force ventilated motors can reduce the commutator wear, Some people call this "Ridging" because of the resulting ridges on each side of the groove.


Copper Drag - occurs when high energy transfers copper in a molten state. These particles become coated by contaminants from the surrounding environment or the brush treatment and do not oxidize properly to form the film on the commutator surface. These particles accumulate at the edge of the bar, eventually shorting across the insulating mica. This condition needs to be addressed immediately when discovered or serious damage may occur. Chamfering the commutator bar edges is necessary to stop the progression of this condition. 

Morgan Industrial Carbon
| Literature | Contact Us | About Us | News | Home
Locations and Addresses

Tel : 0061 2 9772 5600
Tel : 0061 7 5433 7100
Tel : 0061 3 9551 2377
Tel : 08 9451 9088
Tel : 0011 64 9 836 9220
Tel: +65 6296 0929
Tel: (60) 3 - 5569 3990

Morgan Carbon
A Division of Morgan Crucible